Code Coverage and Postrelease Defects: A Large-Scale Study on Open Source Projects

Pavneet Singh Kochhar (1) , David Lo (1) , Julia Lawall (2) , Nachiappan Nagappan (3)

1 SIS - Singapore Management University
2 Whisper - Well Honed Infrastructure Software for Programming Environments and Runtimes
3 Microsoft Research

Testing is a pivotal activity in ensuring the quality of software. Code coverage is a common metric used as a yardstick to measure the efficacy and adequacy of testing. However, does higher coverage actually lead to a decline in post-release bugs? Do files that have higher test coverage actually have fewer bug reports? The direct relationship between code coverage and actual bug reports has not yet been analysed via a comprehensive empirical study on real bugs. Past studies only involve a few software systems or artificially injected bugs (mutants). In this empirical study, we examine these questions in the context of open-source software projects based on their actual reported bugs. We analyze 100 large open-source Java projects and measure the code coverage of the test cases that come along with these projects. We collect real bugs logged in the issue tracking system after the release of the software and analyse the correlations between code coverage and these bugs. We also collect other metrics such as cyclomatic complexity and lines of code, which are used to normalize the number of bugs and coverage to correlate with other metrics as well as use these metrics in regression analysis. Our results show that coverage has an insignificant correlation with the number of bugs that are found after the release of the software at the project level, and no such correlation at the file level.

Mots clés: Empirical study; code coverage; sofware testing; post-release defects; open-source

Domaines: Génie logiciel [cs.SE]

Pavneet Singh Kochhar, David Lo, Julia Lawall, Nachiappan Nagappan. Code Coverage and Postrelease Defects: A Large-Scale Study on Open Source Projects. IEEE Transactions on Reliability, 2017, 66 (4), pp.1213 - 1228. ⟨10.1109/TR.2017.2727062⟩. ⟨hal-01653728⟩